Sydney Flavours
Menu
  • About Sydney Flavours
  • Reviews
  • Sydney’s Best
    • The. Best.
    • Best Bread
    • Best Breakfast and Brunch
    • Best for Business
    • Best Pasta
    • Best Dessert
    • Best Açai
    • Best Ice Cream
    • Best Vegetarian Dishes
    • Best Casual Restaurants
    • Best Healthy
    • Best for Tourists
    • Sydney’s Best Cacio e Pepe
  • OUTSIDE SYDNEY
    • Best in Victoria
      • Attica Review
      • Vue de Monde Review
      • Matilda159 Domain Review
      • Dinner by Heston Review, 2.0
      • Dinner by Heston Review
      • Minamishima Review
      • Kuro Kisume Review
      • Igni Review
      • Sunda Review
      • Brae Review
      • Laura Review
    • Tasmania Reviews
      • Fico Review
    • New York Food & Bars
      • Momofuku Ko Review
      • Le Bernardin Review
      • Cosme Brunch Review
    • Mikla Restaurant Review, Istanbul
  • Ask Me: Recommendations
Menu

Mary’s Underground Review

Posted on by

Jazz at the dinner table.

MENU HIGHLIGHTS Pie; duck fat potato; tortillas; truffle celeriac
VALUE 7/10
AMBIANCE Jazz club. Emphasis on the club
SERVICE Ok
WOULD I GO BACK? For drinking, and music (not conversation)

Mary’s Underground seems like a better venue to go drinking than eating. On most evenings, a few steps down to the sub-street-level restaurant takes you into a screaming den of jazz off Reiby Place in Circular Quay. The venue is dark, with low, red lighting.

Similar to Marys’ other venues, the ‘Get Fat’ theme prevails. The food is enriched by buttery, fatty flavours. Service is punk-rock professional.

Examples of small and pricey options include a single raviolo ($23) filled with an organic egg, pecorino and button mushroom. For $65, you can snag the most enticing, signature item, a dry-aged half duck. Segments of duck are infused with blood orange, and steeped in a persimmon and anise myrtle sauce. With no accompaniments, it’s hardly bang for your buck. The duck skin wasn’t nearly as crunchy, thick and fatty as the masterfully basted birds across the Quay at Mr Wong. With the exception of the jus that came with this duck–which had the yeasty concentration of Vegemite–Mary’s talent shines brightest in its sauces. Plates were scraped clean.

Half a duck with persimmon sauce.
Raviolo.

One such saucy example is the cauliflower velouté, poured over the vegetable pie ($34) filled with chestnut, cabbage and montagne cheese. Second best is the roasted and confit Jerusalem artichoke tortilla ($25), but there’s also a spanner crab, bottarga and salmon roe version on offer ($30). Simply note that your preconceived notion of a tortilla will not match the mound a waiter sets in front of you. It’s more like a thick, round frittata, cut in half.

Vegetable pie.
Jerusalem artichoke tortilla.

Staring off with Cherry Moon malt sourdough ($3) and cultured butter won’t be a mistake, although the roll isn’t fresh enough to be warm. Likewise, the duck fat potato pave ($13) crunches as well as it sounds. The dutch carrots ($15) were my favourite sides, topped by an anchovy crumb.

Duck fat potato pave.

Vegetarians survive the night as equals, if you order the pie, tortilla and truffle celeriac ($34). Roasted and braised zucchini ($12) is rendered acceptable by a scattering of crispy sage and smoked almonds.

Celeriac.
Zucchini.
BBQ garfish with roast lemon and aioli ($32). Not worth the order as there is very little edible flesh to the dish.

I will never miss the opportunity to order a Bomb Alaska for dessert. This version ($18) was heavy on the alcohol, which permeated the meringue too much. The otherwise sweet igloo of eggwhite and ice cream hardly saw the light of day.

Visit dates: 16 & 29 August 2019

Bomb Alaska.

Skip To

  • Oncore by Clare Smyth Review
  • Quay Review, update
  • Cottage Point Inn review, update
  • Jonah’s Review, update
  • Woodcut Review
  • a’Mare Review
  • The Gidley Review
  • Tetsuyas Review
  • Sixpenny Review, update
  • Berowra Waters Inn Review
  • One Penny Red Review
  • Ormeggio 2.0 Review
  • Restaurant Leo Review
  • Chin Chin Review
  • Mary’s Underground Review
  • Sunda Review
  • Arthur Review
  • Brae Review
  • Firedoor Review
  • Pilu at Freshwater, update
  • Chuuka Review
  • Orana Review (‘Orana – in residence’)
  • Sokyo Review: the restaurant
  • Osteria Francescana Review
  • Grossi Grill Review
  • Matilda159 Domain Review
  • Dinner by Heston Review, 2.0
  • Continental Delicatessan Review
  • Biota Review
  • Nel. Review
  • Sean’s Panaroma Review
  • Poly Review
  • Quay Review
  • Minamishima Review
  • Sushi Dai Review
  • Kuro Kisume Review
  • Den Review
  • Narisawa Review
  • Sokyo Review: the omakase
  • Saké Review
  • Cottage Point Inn Review
  • The Apollo Review
  • LuMi Dining Review
  • Zushi Barangaroo Review
  • 10 William St Review
  • Rockpool Review
  • Ormeggio Review
  • Dinner by Heston Review
  • Igni Review
  • Attica Review
  • Spice Temple Review
  • Toko Review
  • Vue de Monde Review
  • Cirrus Review
  • Sunset Sabi Review
  • Fratelli Paradiso Review
  • Mr Wong Review
  • Momofuku Seiōbo Review
  • Fred’s Review
  • Sixpenny Review
  • Pilu Review
  • Ester Review
  • Jonah’s Review
  • Bennelong Cured and Cultured Review
  • Lucio’s Review
  • Sasaki Review
  • Chula Review
  • Hubert Review
  • Sotto Sopra Review
  • Automata Review
  • ACME Review
  • Saint Peter Review
  • Bert’s Review
  • Barangaroo House Review

MORE EETS

  • About
  • Ask Me: Recommendations
  • Best Açai
  • Best Bread
  • Best Breakfast and Brunch
  • Best Cacio e Pepe
  • Best Dessert
  • Best for Tourists
  • Best Ice Cream
  • Best in Melbourne
  • Best Pasta
  • Cosme Brunch Review
  • Fico Review
  • Laura Review
  • Le Bernardin Review
  • Mikla Restaurant Review, Istanbul
  • Momofuku Ko Review
  • New York Food & Bars
  • OUTSIDE SYDNEY
  • Reviews
  • Tasmania Reviews
  • The. Best.
  • XO Review
© 2022 Sydney Flavours | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme