Sydney Flavours
Menu
  • About Sydney Flavours
  • Reviews
  • Sydney’s Best
    • The. Best.
    • Best Bread
    • Best Breakfast and Brunch
    • Best for Business
    • Best Pasta
    • Best Dessert
    • Best Açai
    • Best Ice Cream
    • Best Vegetarian Dishes
    • Best Casual Restaurants
    • Best Healthy
    • Best for Tourists
    • Sydney’s Best Cacio e Pepe
  • OUTSIDE SYDNEY
    • Best in Victoria
      • Attica Review
      • Vue de Monde Review
      • Matilda159 Domain Review
      • Dinner by Heston Review, 2.0
      • Dinner by Heston Review
      • Minamishima Review
      • Kuro Kisume Review
      • Igni Review
      • Sunda Review
      • Brae Review
      • Laura Review
    • Tasmania Reviews
      • Fico Review
    • New York Food & Bars
      • Momofuku Ko Review
      • Le Bernardin Review
      • Cosme Brunch Review
    • Mikla Restaurant Review, Istanbul
  • Ask Me: Recommendations
Menu

Arthur Review

Posted on by

Simple, healthy, quality, contemporary food.

SET MENU HIGHLIGHTS Pork; vanilla slice
VALUE 7/10
AMBIANCE Surry Hills home dining
SERVICE Great
WOULD I GO BACK? If I’m taking a vegetarian

You need to do your research before coming to Arthur, otherwise the inflexibility of the restaurant’s menu might be a shock, particularly to your pocket. Arthur works out to be $80 per person, with absolutely no choice regarding what you’re served (apart from dietary requirements). I dined with a vegetarian friend, and three carnivores – we tried the vegetarian version of each dish, and it was consistently better than the protein-based dishes. I’d highly recommend impersonating a vegetarian for the night if you’re not allergic to greens. Nevertheless, if I was a vegetarian I’d feel a bit ripped off paying $80 – they’re not using expensive ingredients.

My two biggest criticisms of Arthur are the portion sizes, and the serving style. I disliked how small the portions were considering the meal was share-style. Sharing one small plate between three people (see pics below) meant, for instance, eating one thin slice of tomato each; one carrot each; or only having one third of a small fish fillet. This is not well adapted to sharing. Nor was the food itself appropriate for sharing. (Who shares a fish fillet? Or an already small tomato salad loaded with tiny elements which had to be dished out painfully evenly in order for everyone to taste everything?)

There’s also a bit of wankery involved in the decorative flowers and organic-sounding sprinkles of bush dust swallowed undetected.

The dish descriptions are typically mysterious and misleading, to the extent you don’t know the form or quantity of any ingredient listed. It’s been fashionable for a while for restaurants only to list the main flavours/ingredients in a dish. For instance, “vanilla, berries, malt” turns out to be a vanilla slice, possessing an upper layer of berry jelly, served with whipped malt cream. “Carrot, verjuice, nasturtium” is a carrot and white wine puree topped with four small carrots. 

Other dishes answered more to their labels, since they were just that simple. “Dry aged Borrowdale pork loin, leeks, mustard greens” was a sliced lineup of porky softness, sided by token greens. 

To begin, we all get a slice of well-risen Arthur’s sourdough. It’s not warm. The cultured butter is your usual Pepe Saye type. This is the standard I expect of one-hatted basics. 

Tightly packed in a circular pond of oil sits a kangaroo tartare with bush tomato, shallot and mountain pepper. It’s superb when stacked on the bread, but they’re cheating here a bit. Serving the bread at the same time as the tartare means the one slice you’re allocated has to double as your tartare vehicle. They should have separate crackers/vehicles for the tartare. 

One scallop each, with flavour that was hard to detect. This dish certainly wasn’t buttery.

The tomato dish was fresh, but ultimately hugely lacking lardo. After being divided into three portions, I only got one almost invisible lardo strip (and only one disc of tomato).

The lamb fat must have been used to roast the beetroot in, because this dish didn’t taste particularly fatty or rich.

The mango parfait must have been removed from the freezer just before being served, because it was far too hard to eat when it arrived at the table. We had to wait a while for it to defrost. The mango flavour was too subtle. The best part about this dessert was the macadamia biscuit on top.

Overall, you come away feeling clean and lean (and hungry!) I wouldn’t go back unless I was on a health kick or bringing a vegetarian, because it’s neither super tasty nor filling. None of the dishes were terrible though, and I enjoyed the consistent standard. They seem to have the potential to do better.

Visit date: 12 December 2019

Arthur’s sourdough, cultured butter.
Kangaroo, bush tomato, shallot, mountain pepper.
Dry aged Borrowdale pork loin, leeks, mustard greens.
Carrot, verjuice, nasturtium.
Scallop, roe, turnip, brown butter.
Green tomato, fennel, lardo, peppers.
Blue eye trivially, radish, snow pea shoots, peas.
Beetroot, blood plum, chicory, lamb fat.
Vegetarian scallop replacement: squash and chopped onion etc.
Vegetarian fish replacement: Leeks! (Value for money?!)
Mango, yoghurt, macadamia.
Vanilla, berries, malt.

Skip To

  • Oncore by Clare Smyth Review
  • Quay Review, update
  • Cottage Point Inn review, update
  • Jonah’s Review, update
  • Woodcut Review
  • a’Mare Review
  • The Gidley Review
  • Tetsuyas Review
  • Sixpenny Review, update
  • Berowra Waters Inn Review
  • One Penny Red Review
  • Ormeggio 2.0 Review
  • Restaurant Leo Review
  • Chin Chin Review
  • Mary’s Underground Review
  • Sunda Review
  • Arthur Review
  • Brae Review
  • Firedoor Review
  • Pilu at Freshwater, update
  • Chuuka Review
  • Orana Review (‘Orana – in residence’)
  • Sokyo Review: the restaurant
  • Osteria Francescana Review
  • Grossi Grill Review
  • Matilda159 Domain Review
  • Dinner by Heston Review, 2.0
  • Continental Delicatessan Review
  • Biota Review
  • Nel. Review
  • Sean’s Panaroma Review
  • Poly Review
  • Quay Review
  • Minamishima Review
  • Sushi Dai Review
  • Kuro Kisume Review
  • Den Review
  • Narisawa Review
  • Sokyo Review: the omakase
  • Saké Review
  • Cottage Point Inn Review
  • The Apollo Review
  • LuMi Dining Review
  • Zushi Barangaroo Review
  • 10 William St Review
  • Rockpool Review
  • Ormeggio Review
  • Dinner by Heston Review
  • Igni Review
  • Attica Review
  • Spice Temple Review
  • Toko Review
  • Vue de Monde Review
  • Cirrus Review
  • Sunset Sabi Review
  • Fratelli Paradiso Review
  • Mr Wong Review
  • Momofuku Seiōbo Review
  • Fred’s Review
  • Sixpenny Review
  • Pilu Review
  • Ester Review
  • Jonah’s Review
  • Bennelong Cured and Cultured Review
  • Lucio’s Review
  • Sasaki Review
  • Chula Review
  • Hubert Review
  • Sotto Sopra Review
  • Automata Review
  • ACME Review
  • Saint Peter Review
  • Bert’s Review
  • Barangaroo House Review

MORE EETS

  • About
  • Ask Me: Recommendations
  • Best Açai
  • Best Bread
  • Best Breakfast and Brunch
  • Best Cacio e Pepe
  • Best Dessert
  • Best for Tourists
  • Best Ice Cream
  • Best in Melbourne
  • Best Pasta
  • Cosme Brunch Review
  • Fico Review
  • Laura Review
  • Le Bernardin Review
  • Mikla Restaurant Review, Istanbul
  • Momofuku Ko Review
  • New York Food & Bars
  • OUTSIDE SYDNEY
  • Reviews
  • Tasmania Reviews
  • The. Best.
  • XO Review
© 2022 Sydney Flavours | Powered by Superbs Personal Blog theme